top of page

Dressing the part for a 1920s Murder Mystery

Ashley Seybolt

Updated: Jan 18

The 1920s was a decade of glamour, jazz, and intrigue, making it the perfect backdrop for a murder mystery party. Whether you are looking to create a costume from scratch, find thrifted treasures, or splurge on a high-end outfit, there are plenty of options to help you embody the spirit of the Roaring Twenties. This article will guide you through various approaches to dressing for your 1920s murder mystery, with suggestions for both men and women.

Woman in elegant black dress holds a pearl necklace. Background features dim lighting and decorative elements. Glamorous and poised mood.

DIY Costumes

If you’re feeling crafty, a DIY costume can be a fun and budget-friendly option. Here are some ideas:

Women’s DIY Options:

  • Flapper Dress: Use a simple shift dress as a base and add fringe, sequins, or beads. Consider using a sewing machine or fabric glue to attach embellishments.

  • Headband: Create a flapper headband using a strip of fabric or elastic, adorned with feathers or a brooch for an authentic touch.

  • Accessories: Make your own pearl necklace with faux pearls and string, or create a long cigarette holder from a paper straw.

Men’s DIY Options:

  • Suit: A classic suit can be made more 1920s by adding a vest and bow tie. Look for patterns online to create your own vest from fabric.

  • Newsboy Cap: Sew or purchase a simple newsboy cap to complete the look. You can also embellish a plain cap with fabric paint for a unique twist.

  • Accessories: Create a fake mustache using felt or eyeliner and consider adding a pocket watch for a vintage touch.

Thrift Finds

Six people in vintage attire pose dramatically in an elegant room. Gun props, muted gray walls, and intricate trim create a playful, noir vibe.

Thrifting can uncover hidden gems that perfectly capture the essence of the 1920s. Here are some tips on what to look for:

Women’s Thrift Finds:

  • Vintage Dresses: Search for drop-waist dresses, lace, and beaded pieces that reflect the flapper style.

  • Outerwear: Look for a vintage fur stole or a feather boa to add a touch of glamour.

  • Footwear: Seek out T-strap heels or Mary Janes that were popular during the era.

Men’s Thrift Finds:

  • Classic Suits: Look for pinstripe or tweed suits that can be tailored for a perfect fit.

  • Shirts and Ties: Find vintage collared shirts and bow ties or cravats to add character to your outfit.

  • Footwear: Look for leather dress shoes, preferably in a two-tone style that was popular in the 1920s.

Budget-Friendly Options

If you want to keep costs low while still looking fabulous, consider these budget-friendly options:

Women’s Budget-Friendly Options:

  • Rent a Costume: Many costume shops offer rental options for 1920s attire at reasonable prices.

  • Shop Online Sales: Look for sales on online retailers. We've got a list of costumes $40 and under.

  • Accessorize: Sometimes, a simple black dress can be transformed with the right accessories like a feathered headband and pearls.

Men’s Budget-Friendly Options:

  • Costume Rental: Similar to women, consider renting a suit or costume from a local shop.

  • Online Marketplaces: Check online platforms for affordable vintage-inspired clothing. We've got a list of costumes $40 and under.

  • Mix and Match: Pair a modern blazer with vintage trousers for a stylish yet budget-friendly look.

Going All Out: Splurging on Your Costume

Four people in 1920s attire pose happily at a themed party. The setting is a dimly lit room with chandeliers and a lively atmosphere.

If you want to make a statement and are willing to invest in your costume, consider these splurge-worthy options:

Women’s Splurge Options:

  • Designer Flapper Dress: Invest in a high-quality, authentic flapper dress from a designer specializing in vintage fashion. Skills Murder Mysteries has found a selection of ready-to-order dresses that will have you fitting the part.

  • Custom Accessories: Commission a handmade headpiece or jewelry that reflects the opulence of the era.

  • Professional Makeup: Hire a makeup artist to achieve that perfect 1920s glam look.

Men’s Splurge Options:

  • Tailored Suit: Consider having a suit custom-tailored to fit perfectly and reflect the style of the 1920s. Or if you are looking for something more off-the-rack, we've gathered some easy buys.

  • High-End Accessories: Invest in a quality pocket watch or a vintage-style hat from a specialty shop.

  • Grooming: Visit a barber for a classic 1920s haircut and styling for an authentic look.

Dressing for a 1920s murder mystery can be an exciting adventure, whether you choose to create a DIY costume, hunt for thrifted treasures, or splurge on high-end attire. Embrace the glamour and intrigue of the Roaring Twenties, and you’ll be sure to make a lasting impression at your event. Remember, the key is to have fun and express your personal style while capturing the essence of this iconic era!

Comments


bottom of page